Study Questions Relevance of TBI Treatment Guidelines
Research conducted by the Los Angeles County Trauma Consortium suggests that adherence to prior guidelines for treating traumatic brain injuries (TBI) do not necessarily result in better patient outcomes. The guidelines, published more than twenty years ago, have been the industry standard for medical personnel considering a craniotomy or intracranial pressure monitoring for critically injured patients.
Comprised of health researchers from the University of Southern California and UCLA as well as trauma centers and the county’s EMS agency, the consortium concluded that medical providers need to focus on providing “evidence-based care” when treating brain trauma and that much work is needed to improve the quality of hospital care in this arena.
One positive result of the findings, which were published in the journal JAMA Surgery, is that they’ve encouraged consortium members to reassess how they treat brain injury, which could lead to more positive outcomes for patients.
Researchers analyze brain trauma treatment outcomes
The health care researchers evaluated more than 700 adults diagnosed with a traumatic brain injury, and found that hospital compliance rates with the brain trauma guidelines were relatively low across the board. Only 46 percent of patients who needed intracranial pressure monitoring per the guidelines actually had the monitor placed, and just 45.6 percent of those whose trauma called for a craniotomy – where part of the skull is removed — actually had the operation.
Researchers say the mortality rate (patients who died from their TBI) varied from hospital to hospital, ranging from 20 to 50 percent.
“Despite improvements in care, mortality from [traumatic brain injury] remains both common and variable from hospital to hospital,” concluded the study’s authors. “Our results demonstrate no association between hospitals’ compliance with two [Brain Trauma Foundation] guidelines and risk-adjusted mortality, suggesting that neither measure should be used as an independent marker of hospital quality.”
Causes & consequences of TBI
Depending on the severity of the damage, a traumatic brain injury can result in life-altering complications for the victim, ranging from memory loss, slurred speech and poor coordination, to convulsions, seizures and coma.
This sort of injury is most often caused by a sharp blow to the head that damages brain cells and creates swelling and/or bleeding around the brain. TBIs may be caused sport injuries, car accidents, explosions, falls from great heights and acts of physical violence. Those who suffer a severe TBI may be left with permanent cognitive dysfunction, coordination difficulties as well as nerve damage that can cause vision problems and partial paralysis.
Other long-term effects may include behavioral and executive functioning problems, and unfortunately treatments are not always successful and can place tremendous financial burdens on the patients and their loved ones.
Personal injury lawyers in Maine
Hardy, Wolf & Downing know from experience that symptoms of brain trauma are not always evident right away. If you were involved in a car accident, slip and fall or were physically assaulted by another person, it’s imperative to seek medical attention immediately so that doctors can diagnose and treat appropriately.
Residents of Lewiston, Portland, Bangor and throughout the state have relied on our services and legal advocacy for more than four decades, helping victims and their families pursue just compensation when negligence is to blame. To schedule a free consultation with a Maine traumatic brain injury lawyer at our firm, please call 800.465.8733.
- News Medical.net, Compliance with guidelines for treating traumatic brain injury doesn't necessarily translate into better results http://www.news-medical.net/news/20150730/Compliance-with-guidelines-for-treating-traumatic-brain-injury-doesnt-necessarily-translate-into-better-results.aspx
- Mayo Clinic, Traumatic Brain Injury http://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/traumatic-brain-injury/basics/definition/con-20029302
- Goodwill Northern New England, Brain Injury Services https://www.goodwillnne.org/services/health-care/brain-injury-services/